Romelu Lukaku vs. Christian Benteke. Tim Howard vs. Brad Guzan. Everton vs. Aston Villa — and it was Everton that emerged victorious. The win moves Everton into third place, although if either Chelsea or Manchester City grab all three points on Sunday, they’ll slip down into fourth. As for the Villa, it’s down to 14th — and it’s time to start evaluating those that stand in front of Guzan.
Everton’s visit to Villa Park was billed as a “Battle of the Belgians”, yet it was the American goalkeepers that received the majority of the attention, in the first half, anyway. That 45 ended scoreless, but not for want of trying. It was Romelu Lukaku who got things started, waiting to get on the end of a cross, but Aston Villa center back Ron Vlaar did just enough to put him off. Less than ten minutes later, on the other end, fellow Belgian Christian Benteke worked his way inside the area. Seamus Coleman gave him a clip, Benteke went a-tumbling and the referee immediately pointed to the spot.
Benteke himself stepped up to take the penalty, with every Villa fan certain their side would be taking an early lead. The big striker sent his strike to his left, but Tim Howard was ready. The American goalkeeper went diving, using his left hand to push the shot up and over the bar. The resulting corner came to nothing, and the match remained scoreless.
Both Americans had to work hard for the rest of the half to ensure the ball remained out of the net. Howard went diving once more to keep a low shot from Benteke out of the bottom corner. On the other end, Brad Guzan need to be at his best to stop a sharp kick from Lukaku.
But Guzan couldn’t keep out Lukaku forever. In the 68th minute, Everton’s Belgian struck gold. Aston Villa’s defense, weakened by injury to Antonio Luna, fell apart, as they could not work out whether to trail Lukaku or substitute Leon Osman (hint: always Lukaku). Lukaku took advantage, directing his shot between Vlaar and Ciaran Clark. Guzan could do nothing to stop the sharp strike, which landed in the bottom left corner of goal.
Howard, however, was content to confirm his standing as America’s number one keeper, refusing to allow an equalizer. After Gabby Agbonlahor forced the Everton man into a fine save in the 75th minute, Villa looked to be out of ideas. So it was really no surprise when Everton got another minutes later. This time it was Osman himself, sending his shot in from the edge of the area after collecting it from Gareth Barry.
Aston Villa: Guzan, Bacuna, Vlaar, Baker, Westwood, Weimann, Luna (Clark 45), Delph, Agbonlahor, Benteke, Tonev (Helenius 77)
Subs not used: Steer, El Ahmadi, Sylla, Kozak, Lowton
Everton: Howard, Coleman, Jagielka, Distin, Baines, McCarthy, Barry, Mirallas (Deulofeu 90), Barkley (Osman 60), Pienaar (Naismith 80), Lukaku
Subs not used: Joel, Jelavic, Oviedo, Stones
Goals: Lukaku 68′, Osman 81′