Obafemi Martins, Seattle Sounders – Scored Seattle’s second goal in the 58th minute but had an equally good (and remarkably saved) finish in the 17th minute. Acting as a focal point in Sigi Schmid’s impromptu 4-3-3, Martins’ holdup play helped Seattle produce its best performance of the season, a description that also applies to the Nigerian’s individual effort in Montréal.
We could be wrong about: Robbie Keane, LA Galaxy
Fabian Castillo, FC Dallas – Things can get easy when you have Blas Pérez and Mauro Díaz on your side, but as we see on a game-in, game-out basis, opportunities don’t always translate to execution. Castillo continuously created chances for his team until he opened the scoring in the 71st minute, helping Dallas to a 3-1 win over Chivas USA.
Bernardo Anor, Columbus Crew – A two-goal, first half outburst from the Venezuelan built Columbus’s lead in what turned out to be the weekend’s best match. His long distance strike in first half stoppage time will be one of the goals of the season.
Mauro Díaz, FC Dallas – This week it was about quality over quantity for the FCD playmaker. His 71st minute chip over Chivas USA’s high line burned the Goats ahead of Saturday’s opening goal, while his long ball behind left back Tony Lochhead on Dallas’s second set up Je-Vaughn Watson’s game winner.
Wil Trapp, Columbus Crew – A dominant performance in the middle of the park for Columbus’s 21-year-old anchor appeared on the highlight reels when he dispossessed Vincent Nogueira ahead of Anor’s bomb. Involved in both Crew goals, Trapp has just as much of a Player of the Week claim as his teammate, if not more so.
Michael Bradley, Toronto FC – It was a typical Bradley performance, but against a D.C. United midfield that offered no resistance, both he and Jonathan Osorio were allowed to have big days. Bradley, however, sparked the movement for the first goal as well as managed the game while Toronto spent the first hour breaking their visitors down. Add in the qualities that make him a perpetual candidate for this team, and the U.S. international earns the nod.
We may be wrong about: Federico Higuaín, Columbus; Dax McCarty, New York; Osvaldo Alonso, Seattle; Je-Vaughn Watson, Dallas; Dillon Powers, Colorado
DeAndre Yedlin, Seattle Sounders – A couple of shaky moments when Seattle started to bunker may have stuck in people’s minds, but around those hiccups, Yedlin gave his best performance of what’s already a strong sophomore season. Montréal, leaning toward its right, stayed away from Yedlin for the first half-hour, after which the U.S. hopeful was involved in everything. Both in defense and in possession, Yedlin made the right choices on Sunday.
Chad Marshall, Seattle Sounders – Why more people aren’t talking about Marshall’s performance, I don’t know, but the offseason import for Columbus was a rock for Sigi Schmid in Montréal. As if tuned into the Impact attacks, Marshall continuously and calmly cleared Montréal’s forays toward goal, helping Stefan Frei post a relatively easy shutout. He made this choice easy.
Ibrahim Sekagya, New York Red Bulls – Starting in place of the suspended Armando, Sekagya was excellent on Sunday, especially in the air. Particularly on chances in the 73rd and 93rd minutes in Chicago, Sekagya came up big, part of the reason the Red Bulls were able to take a point out of Toyota Park.
Jair Benítez, FC Dallas – What was supposed to be a matchup between him and Chivas USA right midfielder Mauro Rosales never materialized. Instead, Benítez used the space he was afforded to have an impact going forward, especially as Dallas turned up the heat in the second half.
We may be wrong about: Aaron Wheeler, Philadelphia; Josh Williams, Columbus; Matteo Ferrari, Montréal, Nat Borchers, Real Salt Lake; Carlos Bocanegra, Chivas USA
Bill Hamid, D.C. United – Good Bill showed up in Toronto on Saturday, part of the reason D.C. was able to hold out for an hour against one of the best teams in the league. His first half, point-blank save on Jermain Defoe was the big one.
We may be wrong about: Steve Clark, Columbus