Three things we learned in Manchester City’s derby demolition of Manchester United

4 Comments

Following Manchester City’s comfortable 3-0 win over Manchester United pointed out plenty of things on Tuesday night.

Most notably, the balance of power in Manchester has shifted seismically towards the Blue half of the city.

From start to finish Manuel Pellegrini’s Man City took the game to United, and their relentless high-pressing and clinical finishing paid off. With this crucial win, City are now second in the league and just three points behind leaders Chelsea with two games in hand.

(MORE: Man United 0-3 Man City: Dzeko’s double hands City derby delight)

City are in the driving seat to win the PL crown, as United’s fans look on longingly from way down seventh as their ‘noisy neighbors’ are making quite the racket once again.

Let’s see exactly what we learned from yet another derby day demolition from City.

  • David Silva’s superb form will give Man City an extra edge in the run-in
source:
Silva’s pass map n the first half of City’s win over United. The playmaker just kept popping up everywhere. Source: Squawka.

Less than a minute. That’s how long it took for City to take the lead and deflate the electric atmosphere United’s home fans created. David Silva was at the center of Edin Dzeko’s opener as the diminutive Spaniard surged from the edge of the box toward the goal and created havoc. Rafael blocked Silva’s shot but Dzeko followed up to slot it home, as all game long Silva’s first-touch was sensational. United just couldn’t mark him, and the little man kept popping up in spaces behind Dzeko to devastating effect. Away at Hull last weekend just after City had gone down to 10-men, Silva curled in a world-class strike from 30-yards out to help grab a vital three points. He was the fulcrum of the Citizens attack and the heartbeat of their creativity once again on Tuesday. In recent weeks Silva has stepped it up when its really mattered, that’s the sign of a stellar player, and often a season curtailed by niggling injuries the Spanish sensation has regained the form which catapulted City to the PL title back in 2012.

If Silva keeps this form up, City will win the title at a canter this time.

(MORE: David Moyes takes responsibility for ‘disappointing’ derby before walking out of press conference)

  • City’s defensive nous key in next two huge away games

With plenty written about City’s marvelous attacking talents this season — and rightly so after they’ve smashed in 79 goals in 29 games — but City kept their fifth clean sheet in a row in the English top-flight. They haven’t done that since 1915. With the defensive unity looking incredible solid, shielded by the excellent Fernandinho, two big away games against Arsenal this Saturday, and then Liverpool on April 13 will likely determine if the Citizens will win their second PL title. Having Vincent Kompany back at the heart of their defense is key, plus Martin Demichelis has shaken off his nightmare in the FC Barcelona defeat and is now showing his fine pedigree as a defender.

Both full backs are reliable and add impetus going forward, but with trips to Arsenal and Liverpool coming up they have to be content with not having the lions share of possession and defending patiently throughout both matches. If they can shut out those two title challengers, they’ll give themselves one hand on the title.

  • Manchester United’s backbone needs rebuilding
source: Getty Images
City ran rings around United all night long, as new signings Fellaini and Mata continue to underwhelm at Old Trafford.

All season long, when things look to be heading back on track for United they’ve faltered. Once again that was the case, as they’ve now lost 10 times in a single Premier League season for the first-time in club history. Six of those games have been at home, losing all three against their North West rivals Everton, Liverpool and Manchester City without scoring. There’s no way we can dig deep into United’s plethora of problems here, quite frankly I could write a thesis on it. But it’s clear the spine of the side needs rebuilding. Two quality central defenders, a strong holding midfielder and a lively forward who can tear up opposition defenses with pace, something neither Wayne Rooney or RVP possess. With Nemanja Vidic gone and Rio Ferdinand on the way out, we’ve seen time and time again that Phil Jones and Chris Smalling aren’t good enough. In midfield the holding players are aging, Michael Carrick and Darren Fletcher, while Tom Cleverley can’t quite cut it when it matters.

David Moyes needs to spend big, but right now after his buys in the last two windows, you have to question whether Juan Mata and Marouane Fellaini were panic acquisitions or the right players to fight into United’s age-old philosophy of fast-paced attacking soccer. During the first half when United started to gather some steam, Mata was found on the edge of the box with the ball, but waited an age, then cut back inside and played the ball back to the defense. Their was no offensive urgency. That’s been a huge issue for the Red Devils. They need to find two-way players who can keep the ball and drive forward with it. For too long on Tuesday City were able to keep the ball and pass it around United’s players who were off the pace. United were nowhere near good enough, as the need for reinforcements is clear for all to see.

Lukaku or Morata; who got the better deal?

Getty Images
Leave a comment

Romelu Lukaku or Alvaro Morata, who ya got?

[ MORE: Keys to Manchester derby in Houston ]

It’s one of the biggest questions swirling around after Chelsea agreed a $92 million fee with Real Madrid for striker Alvaro Morata on Wednesday, who has arrived in London and called Chelsea “the best club” for him.

He also admitted he has no idea how close he came to signing for Manchester United and Morata could have easily ended up at United and Lukaku at Chelsea, but the opposite is now true as both Premier League giants have acquired clinical strikers who will be the focal point of their respective attacks.

Both Morata and Lukaku have the potential to be the two best out-and-out strikers in the world for many years to come.

[ MORE: Lukaku promises goals for Man United

In terms of who got the better deal, financially both players will end up costing a very similar amount with the fee for Lukaku set to rise to $96.5 million and Morata’s fee just below that. Both players are 24 years of age, and both have very similar skill sets which is understandable given why both United and Chelsea went for them.

So, all square there.

In terms of Premier League experience Lukaku obviously had the edge with the Belgian now playing four full seasons in the PL, while Morata has only played in Spain and Italy. Lukaku is much more likely to hit the ground running as he knows what to expect and is settled in England.

That said, Morata’s experience in the UEFA Champions League is vastly superior to Lukaku’s and the Spanish international also has 13 trophies (including two UCL trophies) to his name already. Lukaku may have more experience in England, but Morata has more experience in elite club competitions and has scored crucial goals in title-winning seasons for both Real and Juve.

Looking at the way both of the players will fit into their teams, it’s difficult to argue that they’re not well suited to both the system and personnel around them.

Lukaku has had many seasons as a lone front man but he could play up top alongside Marcus Rashford which may actually benefit him with someone to work off of and a little more space for him to work in.

Morata will be a lone forward in Chelsea’s attack, but he is flexible and able to play out wide or drop a little deeper when needed and that will work well with Eden Hazard, Pedro and Willian buzzing around in support. Both of these players are more than a target man but you’d have to say Morata appears to be the more creative with the ball at his feet, so he gets the edge.

How can we judge these deals on some kind of scale? Well, the goal tally at the end of the season for each striker will tell the story of who was the better signing. It’s as simple as that and both will be expected to score at least 15-20 goals in all competitions.

But I know you guys don’t like simple answers, so here’s a ranking on some of the key categories which may help us to answer which club spent their $90 million-plus better.

Finishing (out of 10)
Lukaku: 8
Morata: 9

Power
Lukaku: 9
Morata: 8

Pace 
Lukaku: 9
Morata: 8

Aerial ability
Lukaku: 8
Morata: 9

Hold-up play
Lukaku: 7
Morata: 8

Mentality
Lukaku: 7
Morata: 9

Total score
Morata: 51/60
Lukaku: 48/60

Monaco report clubs to FIFA over Kylian Mbappe contact

Getty Images
Leave a comment

AS Monaco are not happy at all.

Star striker Kylian Mbappe is wanted by every top club in the world with the 18-year-old bursting onto the scenes last season as he scored 26 goals in all competitions with Monaco winning Ligue 1 and reaching the UEFA Champions League semifinals.

The French champions released the following strongly-worded statement on Thursday after they’ve already sold Tiemoue Bakayoko to Chelsea, Bernando Silva to Manchester City and both Benjamin Mendy and Fabinho are being chased by Europe’s top clubs.

“AS Monaco regretfully notice that important European football clubs made contacts with Kylian Mbappe (and his entourage) without its authorization. AS Monaco want to remind to these clubs that such actions are contrary to the article 211 of the Administrative regulation of the French Football League (Ligue de Football Professionnel) and to the article 18.3 of the Regulation of the Status and the Transfer of the Players of FIFA.

“To put an end to this unacceptable situation, AS Monaco consider asking the French Football League (Ligue de Football Professionnel) and the FIFA to commit disciplinary procedures against clubs offenders.”

Reports state that Paris Saint-Germain and Manchester City are among the clubs reported to FIFA.

Southampton had a similar situation earlier this summer where they made a complaint over the conduct of Liverpool with regards to their star defender and team captain Virgil Van Dijk. Liverpool ended up issuing a public apology and stated that would end their interest in the player.

The secret world of “tapping up” is now coming out into the open with serious sanctions potentially awaiting any parties found guilty of not following the proper procedures.

Who is “winning” the summer transfer window?

Leave a comment

With big-money deals being done all the time, let’s take a look at how each Premier League club have fared so far in the summer transfer window.

[ MORE: Latest PL transfer news ]

Some have been busier than others and with big deals for Alexandre Lacazette, Romelu Lukaku and now Alvaro Morata spicing things up, we are seeing huge sums flying around among the big boys.

Let’s analyze who is “winning” and “losing” so far this summer with six weeks to go until the window closes on August 31.


Winning

Everton – Seven new players, Rooney has returned and Lukaku cash spenty wisely on defense. More signings promised too.
Chelsea – Morata incoming, plus Bakayoko, Rudiger and Caballero strengthen the squad. Very good summer, so far, despite Costa.
Man City – Overpaid for Walker but have Ederson in goal and Danilo said to be on the way. Bernardo Silva a quality buy.
Bournemouth – Shrewd summer of spending for the Cherries: Begovic, Ake and Defoe arriving. Perfectly blend of youth and experience.

Getting there

Man United – Lukaku and Lindelof were costly but just what they needed. If Matic arrives then Mourinho has had a good summer.
West Ham United – Hart and Zabaelta will bring experience. If they land Arnautovic and Chicharito then a very good window.
Liverpool – Salah will be a star, while Robertson and Solanke will contribute but getting a new center back in is a must.
Huddersfield Town – 10 new arrivals for the Terriers and some real quality in Mounie, Mooy and Williams. Need one or two more players.
Leicester – Iborra, Maguire and Jakupovic upgrades and Iheanacho on the way. Mahrez should only leave for the right price.
Burnley – Walters, Cork and Taylor all good additions, but just lacking a new center back.

Work to do

Stoke – Losing Arnautovic means Hughes must have some deals up his sleeve. Zouma and Delph likely to arrive. New striker a must.
Newcastle – Slow going for Rafael Benitez so far this summer. Murphy and Atsu have arrived in attack, but midfield is the problem area.
Crystal Palace – Loftus-Cheek a solid addition but Frank De Boer needs 2/3 quality additions to avoid a relegation scrap.
Brighton – Hughton is sticking to his budget but the Seagulls should look to add another striker and center mid. Ryan a good get.
Swansea Paul Clement is likely to lose Sigurdsson and with Llorente out injured, new attackers key. Bony to return?

Fine as things stand

Tottenham – After selling on Walker for big money, Spurs will look to invest it shrwedly. All about keeping hold of their stars.
Southampton – Same story for Saints who have added Bednarek in defense and sold Rodriguez. One more striker and defender key.
WatfordMarco Silva should be okay with what he has after adding Chalobah and Hughes in midfield. Replacement for Deeney up top?
West Brom – Rodriguez has slotted in well and Pulis has brought in Ghazi in defense. Solid summer so far and not much needed.
Arsenal – Alexandre Lacazette’s arrival is key, but Arsenal’s summer appears to hinge on the Sanchez and Ozil decision.

3 things to look for in the Manchester derby in Houston

Getty Images
Leave a comment

Manchester City and Manchester United square off in Houston, Texas on Thursday in what will be the first-ever Manchester derby played outside of the UK.

[ MORE: Daley Blind chat to JPW ]

This game is never a friendly but with it being a preseason match-up in the International Champions Cup, we may not see as many challenges flying as we usually do when Jose Mourinho and Pep Guardiola lock horns. Maybe…

It will also be an occasion for both clubs to pay tribute to the victims of the Manchester Bombing attack in May with both teams to display the “worker bee” logo on their shirts for the game.

Here’s a quick look at three intriguing storylines heading into the game.


New kids on the block

This will be our first chance to see Kyle Walker, Ederson and Bernardo Silva in Man City shirts as Pep’s team kick off their preseason games. Walker is a big upgrade on City’s previous full back options and his pace and power will give them a new dynamic and balance. Ederson is now the go-to goalkeeper for Guardiola, even though he said Claudio Bravo will stick around and Bernando Silva is a true luxury player capable of slotting in wherever needed in attack. All three will have plenty to prove with big price-tags hanging around their necks, but perhaps Ederson is the most intriguing because the goalkeeper position has been a huge problem area for City and we know what to expect from Walker and Silva. First impressions can shape your future at a club and Ederson will be well aware of that.

Kompany vs. Lukaku

One big man against another, there’s no love lost between Belgium teammates Vincent Kompany and Romelu Lukaku. This battle will set the tone for the upcoming clashes this season and it is a pivotal one. Kompany can handle Lukaku’s power and aerial ability, but can he handle his pace in-behind? If United can set Lukaku free, there are still doubts over Kompany’s fitness and if the 31-year-old has lost a yard of pace over the years. A supreme defender, Kompany knows this is a massive year for him to stay fit as he will try to lead City to PL glory and then Belgium to World Cup glory next summer with Lukaku by his side. On Thursday in Houston it should be a titanic battle if they come up against one another.

3-4-3 system from United?

I spoke with Man United’s utility man Daley Blind earlier this week and he told me that preparations for a 3-4-3 system is going well. When this alternate formation is deployed, Blind will likely slot in as the left-sided center back with Eric Bailly and Victor Lindelof alongside him. Mourinho usually keeps it simple and plays a 4-2-3-1 formation, but now is the time to experiment and given the recent success of teams playing with wing-backs (Chelsea for most of last season, then Spurs and Arsenal towards the end) why not see if his team can do it?

United have been working on it in training and have already played that way against LA Galaxy in preseason. With United’s fans urging them to be more attack-minded, maybe Mourinho, like Wenger, could change his ways. If United do play wing-backs it will be interesting to see how City’s attackers cope with having to track back and having players in the space they’d usually roam free in.