Though the second finalist won’t be determined until tomorrow, Toluca’s Tuesday night win over Alajuelense in CONCACAF Champions League’s semifinals ensures recent history will repeat itself. While this year’s final won’t be another Monterrey-Santos Laguna affair, the Red Devils’ outset of the Costa Ricans means two Liga MX teams will contest CONCACAF’s title for the fourth time in five years, with no other federation having claimed the region’s crown since the competition changed format in 2008.
On Tuesday, up 1-0 after their victory in Costa Rica last week, Toluca got goals from Carlos Esquivel and Juan Manuel Salgueiro, recovering from the Erizos’ early challenge to post an easy 2-0 (3-0, aggregate) victory. The two-time confederation champions now await the winner of Tijuana-Cruz Azul, with Xolos having earned a 1-0 lead last week at Estadio Caliente.
Regardless of what happens on that side of the draw, Toluca’s win guarantees Mexico’s monopoly of Champions League will continue. For the ninth straight tournament — a time that extends back to the old Champions Cup — a Mexican team will be crowned champions. Were it not for Real Salt Lake’s appearance in the 2010-11 finals, each finalist since the tournament’s redesign would have been Mexican, with 16 of the competition’s 24 semifinalists having hailed from Mexico’s league.
Go back further, and the picture is only slightly more diverse. Since Major League Soccer came into existence in 1996, three different federations have claimed CONCACAF’s title, but only Mexico has held the crown since 2006. In 2005, Saprissa made it back-to-back titles for Costa Rica, with Alajuelense having won the previous year. Slightly before that, MLS claimed this only titles with D.C. United (1998) and LA Galaxy (2000) each winning one title.
Tomorrow, Cruz Azul will try to turn around its one-goal deficit against visiting Tijuana, but the story of Mexico’s dominance has already been written. In 2014, the league’s hegemony continues, with the league set to claim a 30th CONCACAF title.