Brazil-Colombia referee forced to explain himself outside airport bathroom

8 Comments

Few Brazil or Colombia fans will feel much sympathy for Carlos Velasco Carballo, the referee who presided over yesterday’s quarterfinal, but when you hear about English media and soccer fans waiting for him outside a restroom in Rio de Janeiro’s airport, the story around his Friday decisions takes on a much stranger feel. After all, how many of us have to worry about being hounded about our job performance when we’re getting off an airplane?

It’s a loaded comparison considering Carballo knows his job is in the public eye, but it’s still a bit insane that the guy couldn’t go to the bathroom after getting off his flight without having to explain what happened in a soccer game. Yet there he was, according to The Observer, having to explain himself to a Colombia fan who wanted more fouls called on Brazil.

Carballo presided over Brazil’s 2-1 win over Colombia, a victory that put the Selecao into the World Cup semifinals amid discontent about his officiating. Colombia fans bemoaned the cynical nature of Brazil’s fouls on star midfielder James Rodriguez, while the host nation was left heart-broken after a late-match challenge from Juan Camilo Zuñiga broke one of Neymar’s vertebra, ending the stand-out attacker’s tournament.

English media who happened to be on the same Saturday flight from Fortaleza were also able to get some time with CarballoFrom The Guardian’s website:

One Colombian fan waited for him outside the toilets … The Spanish official appeased her by agreeing to a photograph.

A smiling Carballo then explained to the Guardian and Observer’s chief football writer, Daniel Taylor, why he could not talk in detail about his performance … “Unfortunately I cannot talk about it. I would like to but the rules do not allow it … I can talk to you about Manchester United or Chelsea or José Mourinho or anything else, but not this, thank you.”

Am I wrong for thinking it’s over-the-line to pursue this man outside an airport bathroom? If not, at what point is he allowed to go on with his life? Is there a window in which it’s socially acceptable to confront Carballo about his performance? And if so, why isn’t that window shorter?

Yesterday’s game was important, but it was ultimately just a game, no matter what emotions those 90 minutes inspire after the final whistle.

For the media, there is a certain journalist responsibility to pursue stories, but that same press should have known what the answer would be. Regardless, this isn’t hard news. We’re not pursuing national security secrets, here.

Do we really want to be feeding into an environment where lingering outside restrooms for match officials could possibly be rewarded? I thought, as a civilization, we’d agreed that TMZ was gross?

If there’s a huge societal demand for answers, the media can work through FIFA to amend rules that prevent him from talking about his decisions. That’s assuming that societal demand should even be rewarded.

But at the point we’re taking these professional concerns into Carballo’s private life, we’ve gone too far. This is a slippery slope, but one that’s led to some ugly incidents in more malicious hands.

 

Day Four: All the action from the U20 World Cup

Hong Hae-in/Yonhap via AP
Leave a comment

South Korea and Venezuela clinched berths in the knockout rounds of the U-20 World Cup on Tuesday, while Germany and Argentina have surprising work to do after two matches in South Korea.

[ MORE: Allardyce steps down at Palace ]

South Korea 2-1 Argentina

Barcelona B man Lee Seung-woo helped South Korea take a 2-0 lead, then hold on for the win and group lead over England.

England 1-1 Guinea

Chelsea youngster Fikayo Tomori scored a wild long range own goal to cost England the three points, but the Blues are still well-positioned to advance out of the group stage. Bournemouth midfielder Lewis Cook scored for England, and it was a beaut.

Venezuela 7-0 Vanuatu

Seven different Venezuelans have scored through a pair of shutout wins, with Caracas’ Sergio Cordova the only one to bag a pair.

Mexico 0-0 Germany

Germany has just one point through two matches, thanks largely to Pachuca’s Abraham Romero’s seven saves. Mexico was outshot 12-6.

Porto, Watford, Hull? Marco Silva in demand

Photo by Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images
Leave a comment

Marco Silva is one of the hottest properties in management, months after eliciting cries of “Who?” following his appointment at Hull City.

While those cries may have been a tiny bit myopic given his time at Sporting CP and Olympiacos, the 39-year-old is now visible to the world despite Hull’s relegation.

[ MORE: Real Madrid nabs $50m teen ]

Silva will be back in England to meet with Hull on Wednesday, but a clause in his contract that said he could leave if the club was relegated gives the Tigers very little hope.

Rumors have him wanted at Watford, and he’s also been linked with a number of other jobs including Southampton (should the club part ways with Claude Puel).

However, the former right back is also reportedly a target of one of the biggest clubs in his home country: Champions League side Porto.

UEFA Europa League Final preview: Manchester United vs. Ajax

Photo by Mike Hewitt/Getty Images
Leave a comment

Jose Mourinho’s big European gamble takes center stage on Wednesday in Sweden, when Manchester United attempts to topple young Ajax in the UEFA Europa League Final.

United’s chances for UEFA Champions League qualification, a magnificent opportunity, are overshadowed by the pall cast over Manchester by sinister terrorist attacks at a pop concert that killed and injured many on Monday night.

Alas, there’s soccer to be played, and Mourinho is looking to make it a trio of shiny items in his first year on the job. United beat Leicester City for the Community Shield, then topped Southampton in the EFL Cup Final en route to Sweden.

United’s well-documented dearth of healthy defenders will march out one more time on Wednesday, with Chris Smalling and Phil Jones tasked with manning the center of the back line. Expect Antonio Valencia and Matteo Darmian out wide.

[ MORE: Full 2016-17 season reviews

Despite the injury to Zlatan Ibrahimovic, Mourinho’s attack is going to give Ajax fits. Marcus Rashford has been next level for most of the second half of the season, and United will also likely feature Henrikh Mkhitaryan and Paul Pogba atop Ander Herrera.

If someone is going to break United down, it could be midfield wizards Davy Klaassen and Lasse Schone. The creative middle men have a variety of options to find with the ball, including on-loan Chelsea man Bertrand Traore and Danish teenager Kasper Dolberg.

But how will they deal with United’s attack? Sure Ajax has stopped Lyon, Schalke, Copenhagen, and Legia Warsaw, but United and Mourinho? That’s another challenge for Peter Bosz and his men.

Ajax won the 1992 UEFA Cup, and this is United’s first ever trip to this particular final. The Red Devils are heavy favorites, and we expect United to prevail. Don’t sleep on Juan Mata heroics. Call it 3-1.

Allardyce resigns, opening up intriguing vacancy at Palace

Photo by Mike Hewitt/Getty Images
Leave a comment

Sam Allardyce is walking away on top outside the relegation zone.

The veteran Premier League manager, 62, resigned his post as Crystal Palace on Tuesday, weeks after leading another team to safety.

The move ends a tumultuous eight months for Allardyce, who was fired as England manager after an undercover sting exposed unethical dealings with agents.

[ MORE: Full 2016-17 season reviews

It also comes about an hour after somebody wrote that Crystal Palace should move on from Allardyce. What a jerk, that somebody.

Rarely at a loss for words, here’s Big Sam from cpfc.co.uk:

I want to be able to savour life while I’m still relatively young and when I’m still relatively healthy enough to do all the things I want to do, like travel, spend more time with my family and grandchildren without the huge pressure that comes with being a football manager.

This is the right time for me. I have no ambitions to take another job, I simply want to be able to enjoy all the things you cannot really enjoy with the 24/7 demands of managing any football club, let alone one in the Premier League.”

All kidding aside — and I’m far from a Big Sam fan — congrats to the man on walking away to enjoy the finer things in life. He had a heck of a run, and we’ll see how long he can resist being away from the fray. Cheers, Sam.