Not everything is about Landon Donovan, but the critique the United States Men’s National Team’s all-time leading scorer offered yesterday sent ripples through the team’s fan base. Though the Galaxy star, left out of Jurgen Klinsmann’s team for Brazil 2014, gave a considered, dispassionate view when he said the U.S. “were not set up to succeed,” many fans were left wondering if his honesty was too much, too soon in the wake of Tuesday’s loss.
But as another prominent U.S. star from South Africa 2010 reminds us, Donovan’s view is just one man’s opinion. Not every player who’s been left on the wrong side of Klinsmann’s selections was left disappointed. Carlos Bocanegra, for one, was complementary of not only the team’s performance but its approach.
Here’s the former U.S. Men’s National Team captain, as reported by Major League Soccer’s website:
“I would have taken that in a heartbeat,” Bocanegra said (of the U.S.’s World Cup outcome) …
“[The defense] did a good job,” the 35-year-old said. “They were very organized, very disciplined and had a great shape. We were playing against some very difficult teams: Belgium, Germany, Portugal and even Ghana, which has some very dynamic attacking players.
“We’re a smart team and nowadays in the World Cup …We’re going in the right direction.”
Rightfully, Bocanegra’s comments are already being juxtaposed against his former teammate’s, but the criticism of Donovan is going a little too far. Perhaps the timing of his observations was slightly ill-advised, he’s not exactly coming at this the same way as Eric Wynalda. There are others who share Dononvan’s views.
After all, consider Jurgen Klinsmann’s comments in the wake of Tuesday’s loss:
“I’m screaming my lungs off on the sidelines, [trying] to push them higher up the field. This is something they have to get out of their minds. Even against talented teams, [we have] to play them higher and higher up.”
Perhaps the problem is less tactics than on-field execution? To me, it was neither. Both the tactics and performances gave the U.S. a chance to steal results from Belgium and Germany. Donovan and Klinsmann may want more, but given the talent gap between the U.S. and that opposition, it’s unclear a different approach would have left the U.S. within striking distance.
Regardless, there are a number of ways to break down what happened on Tuesday, one of which is Bocanegra’s more positive view. Belgium? Germany? Portugal and Ghana? They’re all pretty good teams. There were no 2010 Algerias on this years docket.
Where Donovan may see a wasted opportunity, Bocanegra sees a great performance. And neither has to be wrong.