The case for each U.S. Soccer Male Player of the Year nominee

Photo by Vaughn Ridley/Getty Images
1 Comment

U.S. Soccer will announce its 2016 individual awards on Friday, and while some winners seem set in stone, the Men’s Player of the Year is anything but an open and shut case.

Christian Pulisic is probably going to edge Jordan Morris for Young Male Player, Carli Lloyd is going to seize Female Player of the Year, and Andi Sullivan will probably take the Young Female honors (though admittedly we’re educated guessing on the last one).

[ MORE: Wednesday’s Champions League preview ]

Three of the men’s nominees have won before: Jozy Altidore in 2013, Michael Bradley last year, and Clint Dempsey in 2007, 2011, and 2012. Bobby Wood and Geoff Cameron complete the ballot.

It’s a bit surprising to see Dempsey’s name given he has missed a lot of time with a heart ailment, but the Sounders man had an electric start to 2016. Fabian Johnson, Bobby Wood, and Christian Pulisic have shouts to be on the list, especially with the former earning 33 percent of the vote last year, but such is life.

A case can be made for each. Let’s make ’em.

Jozy Altidore
Club: Toronto FC — 28 games played, 15 goals, 7 assists
Country: 10 caps, six goals, two assists

Why he could win: Either Altidore or fellow nominee Cameron is the most accomplished active USMNT player not to have won the award. Toronto is on its way to its first final, and Altidore’s played a huge part. Ultimately, his missing the Copa America Centernario through injury probably hurts his cause too much.

Michael Bradley
Club: Toronto FC — 29 games played, 2 goals, 4 assists
Country: 17 caps, three assists

The captain during the 2016 Copa America Centenario success, Bradley was used up and down the pitch by Jurgen Klinsmann. He’s been quite decent for Greg Vanney at Toronto FC, leading the club to the MLS Cup Final. Will his recent USMNT performances hurt him with voters? Probably.

Geoff Cameron
Club: Stoke City — 26 games played, 1 assist
Country: 12 caps, one goal

Was a pivotal player in Stoke’s run up the Premier League table last season, and his absence in the USMNT’s recent losses to Mexico and Costa Rica underscores his value. Will the voters reward a player who doesn’t put up gaudy numbers? A defender hasn’t claimed this award since Oguchi Onyewu in 2006.

Clint Dempsey
Club: Seattle Sounders — 19 games, 10 goals, 1 assist
Country: 10 caps, 4 goals, 4 assists

He didn’t play a ton, but when he did, oh boy. Dempsey was electric in the Copa America Centenario, a “roll back the years” job that hearkened to his time at Fulham. Quietly had a good offensive season for Seattle before his heart procedures. Will the absence be too much for him to overcome with voters?

Bobby Wood
Clubs: Union Berlin – 12 games, 10 goals, 1 assist; Hamburg – 12 games, 4 goals
Country: 15 caps, 4 goals, 3 assists

Doesn’t have the country numbers of Altidore or Dempsey, but has continued to improve and fared well even when used out on the wing. Dominated the 2.Bundesliga and raised his level once joining the Bundesliga before earning a card suspension.

Follow @NicholasMendola