“Better” in sports is an unbelievably misleading word. The LA Galaxy aren’t “better” without 2013 MLS MVP and scorer of 75 goals (to go along with 43 assists) in 111 career MLS games. Of course they’re not. (Same goes for Nigel de Jong as well, probably.)
But there’s no denying that over the last four games — and the last two in particular — in which Keane hasn’t played a single minute due to knee surgery, have seen Bruce Arena’s side strike a much healthier balance between their attack and their defense, resulting in two of the best overall performances we’ve seen in MLS 2016 thus far.
Three tactical adjustments have been made in Keane’s absence. In no particular order, they are: 1) Giovani dos Santos has taken up Keane’s free-roaming, play-making role which suits him much more than being shunted out wide as a winger; 2) Mike Magee’s place in the starting lineup offers the kind of defensive cover that Dos Santos isn’t capable of providing, whether on the left or right; 3) Gyasi Zardes’s deployment through the center has shown that he’s more productive as a striker than as a winger. As a result, the Galaxy are humming right along with near-perfect, best evidenced in Saturday’s 5-2 dismantling of previously-unbeaten Real Salt Lake.
On point no. 2, below is the combined passing-and-defensive-actions diagrams for Juan Manuel “El Burrito” Martinez and Demar Phillips (left), and that of left back Chris Wingert (right), who combined to play all 90 minutes up and down RSL’s left wing, where Magee was ever-present in assisting right back A.J. DeLaGarza. You’ll notice that they 1) are all three pushed extremely wide, and 2) combine to complete all of one pass into the Galaxy’s penalty area. The left wing is a total non-starter for RSL in this one, though the absence of Joao Plata and his ability to operate in the space between the full back and center back on either side was undoubtedly a big miss.
Keane’s return from injury is approaching (he was originally pegged with an early-to-mid-May return date), at which point the Galaxy will undoubtedly be a more talented side on paper, but not necessarily one that fits together and functions at its very best.
Someone from the above list of attackers is headed to the bench upon Keane’s return — not even Arena could get away with sitting a player with more goals and assists combined than games played in his MLS career. It’s easiest to say, “well, Magee is the ‘worst’ player of the bunch, so it should obviously be him,” but it should be one of Zardes or Dos Santos instead.
REFEREEING GAFFES AT CRITICAL MASS
Let’s talk about MLS’s gigantic, growing refereeing problem, because that seems to be what MLS and the Professional Referee Organization want us to do at the end of every MLS weekend.
MLS’s mandate for its referees to officiate games in a stricter manner in an attempt to rid the game of dangerous challenges, thus seeing the number of red cards handed out increase a fair bit over the first month of the season, has been met with plenty of opposition and disdain thus far in 2016. In defense of the league and PRO, though, whether you believe it to be a necessary venture, at least it indicates the two organizations, which work together hand in hand, have considered a course of action to improve the league’s standard of play and protect its players.
Being proactive is typically a good thing, and this instance is no different. What’s not so great, however, were a pair of blown calls on Sunday that saw the league’s two nationally televised games decided (to varying degrees) by something out of the hands of the 22 players on the field.
Referee Jair Marrufo failed to simultaneously award Sporting Kansas City a penalty and show San Jose Earthquakes defender Andres Imperiale a red card when he quite clearly slid through the legs of Dom Dwyer, coming nowhere near the ball in his last-ditch challenge (WATCH HERE). Less than five minutes later, Marrufo (correctly) awarded the Earthquakes a penalty when Tim Melia brought Simon Dawkins down with with contact that was no greater and no less than occurred on the other end of the field. Chris Wondolowski converted the spot kick, and the ‘Quakes won the game 1-0.
Not even four hours later, Hilario Grajeda failed to show Karl Ouimette a red card of his own after the New York Red Bulls defender swiped the legs of Orlando City SC striker Cyle Larin right out from under him with the two racing into the Red Bulls’ penalty area, and an obvious goal-scoring opportunity upon them (WATCH HERE). Orlando City held a 1-0 lead at the time and would have enjoyed a man advantage for the game’s final 27 minutes. Instead, Ouimette stayed on the field (he later scored an inconsequential own goal), the Red Bulls equalized two minutes later, scored again four minutes after that, and went on to win the game 3-2.
After each game’s final whistle, neither referee had any desire to explain their calls — or, non-calls, as it were — that drastically changed the course of two otherwise enjoyable games of soccer (UPDATE).
No accountability for their shortcomings, which is perhaps MLS’s greatest shortcoming with regard to its referees: Marrufo and Grajeda, along with every other ref who erred in costly fashion this weekend and last weekend and the weekend before that and so on, will be right back out there (mis-)managing MLS game next weekend and the weekend after that and so on. PRO general manager Peter Walton will do a controlled interview with some online or television outlet in the coming days or weeks, insist the organization is committed to raising its standard, and we’ll all go back to living our everyday lives.
Expect to see the exact same mistakes in the coming weeks and months, though, and to find yourself wondering yet again, “why did I commit that much of my afternoon/evening/weekend to watching MLS when the guys with the whistles are always the stars of the show?” For a league that’s incredibly brand- and market-conscious, you’d think MLS would move quickly to fix something that’s bound to cost it viewers — and ultimately dollars — if unchanged.
If it’s a solution to the problem that you’re looking for, Orlando City head coach Adrian Heath offered up a pretty good one last week: instead of signing aging foreign players at the end of their playing careers, commit some of that money to recruiting quality refs who have called games at the highest level in order to increase the standard of refereeing, because the quality of play has improved leaps and bounds while the men in the middle of the field seem to have stagnated and/or regressed badly.
TEAM OF THE WEEK
Goalkeeper: David Ousted (Vancouver Whitecaps)
Defenders:Ashley Cole (LA Galaxy), Drew Moor (Toronto FC), Tim Parker (Vancouver Whitecaps)
Midfielders: Emmanuel Boateng (LA Galaxy), Sacha Kljestan (New York Red Bulls), Wil Trapp (Columbus Crew SC) Will Johnson (Toronto FC)
Forwards: Sebastian Giovinco (Toronto FC), Bradley Wright-Phillips (New York Red Bulls), Gyasi Zardes (LA Galaxy)
PLAYER OF THE WEEK
No single player in MLS can take over a game the way that Sebastian Giovinco can do, and so regularly does. With his 22-goal, 16-assist 2015 season still fresh in everyone’s memory, Giovinco is the focal point of every opposition’s defensive gameplan (this was the case last year as well, to little avail), which limits the number of touches, space and chances that come the Atomic Ant’s way during a given game.
So what, the 29-year-old Italian said this week, as he carved up the Montreal Impact for two goals, three massive road points and a bit of revenge for last season’s playoff elimination and embarrassment. A sign of a truly great player is the ability to do a lot with very little, and Giovinco continues to do that week in and week out. His 81st-minute insurance goal was as ruthless as it was comforting for TFC fans.
The game in 100 words (or less): Anytime you check the tags list at the bottom of a game recap, and you find the game’s referee among them, you know something went horribly awry. If you scroll down, you’ll find that Jair Marrufo was in charge of San Jose Earthquakes’ 1-0 victory over Sporting Kansas City at Avaya Stadium on Sunday, and probably deduce (correctly) that he had a shocker of an afternoon and probably (most definitely) greatly affected the outcome of the game. (Video of said shenanigans can be found below.) The victory sees San Jose (14 points) climb to spots in the Western Conference, from sixth to fifth, where they now reside two points ahead of Sporting KC, who presently occupy the sixth and final playoff place out West.
29′ — Bingham leaps across goal to deny Dwyer — Much of the first half was spent this way, with Sporting winning the ball inside the Earthquakes’ half and created quick, easy chances from out wide. David Bingham up to the challenge when called into action, though.
55′ — Dwyer tripped in the box, Marrufo swallows his whistle — This is a truly spectacular no-call on 100-percent, no-doubt-about-it penalty. What’s worse, not only is Marrufo on the scene, but the far-side assistant referee is perfectly positioned as well.
Before we get into comments from the Portland Timbers’ manager, let’s be responsible and frame this thing in the proper context.
Timbers manager Caleb Porter said his team played well in the 1-0 loss. Not perfectly, but pretty well – a pretty accurate assessment. The visitors created better chances in the first half, especially considering they were missing their emotional fulcrum, Will Johnson, but did dropped a notch after the break.
“In the end, we’re going to keep suffering if we don’t find goals and if we don’t sort out set pieces,” Porter said, referring to the ongoing issues with defending corner kicks and free kicks.
That said, Porter also commented (without blaming) referee Jair Marrufo.
To be fair, I thought the officiating was very lopsided, extremely lopsided, for whatever reason. They have guys who commit three, four fouls, the same one, no card, and we commit one and it’s a card. Watch the tape, you explain it because I can’t understand it. We’re talking the same exact foul, same exact foul, we’re doing a foul, they’re doing a foul, and we get a card and they don’t get a card. Explain it. I don’t get it. It makes no sense to me.”
“[Osvaldo Alonso] commits five fouls on Nagbe, no card. We commit one and get a card. How does Alonso not get a card when he fouls a guy five times? Alonso is a tremendous player, and listen, if you can foul a guy like Nagbe five times and not get a card, what are you going to do? You’re going to keep fouling him. He’s smart.”
Indeed, Alonso needed to be booked for about three of those fouls. If nothing else, he needed a card for persistent infringement, the violation on which MLS officials inexplicably refuse to get with the doggone program.
But Marrufo was an equal opportunity poor referee on Sunday at CenturyLink Field.
Timbers center back Pa-Modou Kah was lucky to remain on the field after some of his shenanigans, which included kneeing Eddie Johnson in the head as the Seattle attacker sat on the turf following a tough foul. Does anybody really believe that Kah, a veteran, professional athlete, is so clumsy that he couldn’t avoid belting a stationary object with his knee?
Here’s where this one needs to land: Surely there was a better choice than Marrufo to officiate the league’s showcase match of the entire freaking summer!
Clint Dempsey said it best at the final whistle, when he said the high-profile match was tough and “reckless” at times.
Good referees can wring the “reckless” out of a match with savvy management. Marrufo, with his reputation for “old school” MLS refereeing, where officials allow too much of the rough and tumble and stubbornly prefer not to issue cards that will help control a match, apparently cannot.
That is PRO (the continent’s professional refereeing overseer) and U.S. Soccer match assigners being asleep at the wheel.
Seriously, how do you not understand how many eyes were going to be on this one?
On the one hand, only one teenage ball boy was manhandled, so that’s something, I suppose.
On the other hand, there were so many naughty, naughty boys around MLS in Week 11. There were also some forgiving referees; no red cards were handed out over eight weekend matches.
All of that points to one thing: a busy week for the MLS disciplinary committee, which usually notifies teams by Tuesday of impending suspensions. (The suspensions are typically announced to the public later in the week, following the appeals process, except in instances where mid-week matches move the process forward.)
In Simon Borg’s weekly Instant Replay (which I like to call, “The most overly caffeinated six minutes in American soccer,” and which can be seen at the bottom of this post) we see several suspensions ahead. I don’t agree with Borg on all the reds that deserved to be shown; but for me, here are the reds that should have been issued:
If Johnny Leveron’s late tackle on LA Galaxy attacker Jose Villarreal isn’t red-card worthy, it’s very, very close. That one needs consideration for retro red.
Colorado’s Edson Buddle for his awful tackle (from behind and ridiculously late, with absolutely no effort to get the ball) on Columbus’ Tony Tchani is a clear red in my book.
Sam Cronin’s dangerous stud into Mauro Rosales’ groin needs retroactive action; San Jose’s Cronin gets away with a lot, a prime example of where MLS referees repeatedly fail to adequately warn for persistent infringement or dangerous fouling (and then to take more forceful action once warnings have been delivered). The failure by referee Jair Marrufo’s to even issue a yellow card here was perhaps the biggest blunder from a man in the middle this weekend.
Philadelphia’s Bakary Soumare for planting a shoulder off the ball into the face of Chicago’s Quincy Amarikwa. That’s just brainless.
Chivas USA’s Mario de Luna for pushing a ball boy. Sorry, all you commenters from the other post who don’t think putting hands on a ball boy is worthy of suspension. You are wrong. (And by the way, Borg has great information here, reminding us that league guidelines say a ball boy must return the ball to the appropriate team, which in this case was not Chivas USA. It’s a point certainly worthy of consideration.)
It will be a case of high injustice if Columbus’s Jairo Arrieta does not get suspended for a pretty vicious elbow blow to the face of Colorado’s Drew Moor. Don’t forget, Moor himself was suspended for two games last month for an incident that looks remarkably similar.
By the way, the fast-moving Instant Replay also shows where goals by Montreal’s Marco di Vaio and Colorado’s Buddle should have been waved off. The disciplinary committee, at least, doesn’t have to worry about those.